Hello I'm new to this website. I just wanna talk about the two conflicting isaaq geneologies. The most well known would be the banu hashim one which is arguably the most well known one. Which goes as Ishaq bin Ahmed bin Muhammed bin Hussein bin Ali bin Mudhar bin Abdalla bin Ayub bin Muhammed bin Qasim bin Ahmed bin Ali bin Issa bin Yahya bin Muhammed al-Taqi bin Ali al-Askari bin Muhammed al-Jawad bin Ali al-Ridha bin Musa al-Kadhim bin Jafar al-Sadiq bin Muhammed al-Baqir bin Ali Zainal al-Abiden bin Imam Al Hussein bin Ali bin Abi talib. Another one would be the dir genealogy which goes as
Isaq
Son of Mahamed "Rambade"
Son of Hanaftire
Son of Mahe
Son of Dir
Son of Aji
Son of Irir
Son of Samale
Son of Hil
Son of Abrone
Which one do you think is most accurate and why do some dir members recognise isaaqs as dir?